Aortic stenosis vs aortic regurgitation: how the murmurs differ
One question settles most of it: is the murmur between S1 and S2, or after S2? Hear both real recordings on one heartbeat, then learn where to listen.
Aortic stenosis makes a murmur in systole, between S1 and S2. It rises and then falls, and it is loudest at the right upper sternal border, often carrying up to the neck.1,2 Aortic regurgitation makes a murmur in diastole. It starts right at S2 and fades away, it is high-pitched and blowing, and it is loudest along the left sternal border.1,3 Place the murmur in the heartbeat and you have most of the answer.
| Aortic stenosis | Aortic regurgitation | |
|---|---|---|
| When | Systole, after S11 | Diastole, starting at S21 |
| Shape | Crescendo-decrescendo: rises, then falls1 | Decrescendo: starts loud, then fades1,3 |
| Sound | Harsh2 | High-pitched and blowing1,3 |
| Loudest | Right second intercostal space2,4 | Left sternal border, third and fourth spaces3 |
| Spreads to | The neck and carotid arteries2,4 | No typical spread |
| Best position | Sitting up | Sitting up, leaning forward, breath held5 |
| Other clues | Slow, weak carotid pulse; soft or single S22,4 | Wide pulse pressure and bounding pulses, in long-standing leaks3 |
Is it in systole or diastole?
Every heartbeat has two main sounds. S1 is the mitral and tricuspid valves closing as the ventricles start to squeeze. S2 is the aortic and pulmonic valves closing as they finish. The gap from S1 to S2 is systole, when the heart pumps blood out. The longer gap from S2 back to the next S1 is diastole, when the heart fills.
The aortic valve sits between the left ventricle and the aorta. It should be wide open in systole and tightly shut in diastole. Each lesion breaks one of those two jobs, so each makes its noise in a different half of the beat.
- Aortic stenosis
- Aortic regurgitation
A quick way to find your place: feel the carotid pulse while you listen. The sound just before the pulse is S1, and the sound just after it is S2.5
Why does each murmur sound the way it does?
Aortic stenosis. The valve opens only partway, so the left ventricle has to force blood through a narrow opening.2 Flow builds as the ventricle squeezes harder, then falls off as it empties, and the murmur follows that rise and fall.
Aortic regurgitation. The valve fails to seal, so blood leaks back from the aorta into the left ventricle in diastole.3 The leak begins the moment the valve should close, so the murmur starts right at S2, at its loudest, and then fades.1,3
Where on the chest is each one loudest?
Listen for aortic stenosis at the right second intercostal space, just to the right of the sternum, and follow it up toward the neck: the murmur often carries to the carotid arteries.2,4 If it doesn't reach the right carotid, aortic stenosis is much less likely.6
Listen for aortic regurgitation along the left sternal border at the third and fourth intercostal spaces.3 It is soft and easy to overlook, so sit the patient up, have them lean forward and hold their breath, and listen again.5 The murmur gets louder as they breathe out.3 Hearing an early diastolic murmur is the single most useful finding for aortic regurgitation, and not hearing one makes it much less likely.7
If the diastolic murmur is louder to the right of the sternum than to the left, think of the aortic root, such as a dilated aorta, rather than the valve leaflets alone.8
What else does the exam show?
In aortic stenosis, the carotid pulse can rise slowly and feel weak, a sign called pulsus parvus et tardus.2 S2 may be soft or single.2,6 As the stenosis worsens, the murmur peaks later in systole.4 A slow carotid upstroke, a mid-to-late peak and a soft S2 each make aortic stenosis more likely.6 These findings track severity, but none is reliable enough alone, so an echocardiogram is still needed.9
- Aortic stenosis, S2 present
- Severe aortic stenosis, S2 single or absent
In aortic regurgitation that has been present for a long time, the pulse pressure widens and the pulses feel bounding.3 Some patients also have an Austin Flint murmur, a low rumble in mid-to-late diastole at the apex, thought to come from the regurgitant jet pushing on the mitral valve.3 When regurgitation comes on suddenly, the patient can be very unwell, and the pulse pressure may be normal or only slightly wide.3
Do maneuvers help?
A little. Squatting brings more blood back to the heart and makes both of these murmurs louder. Valsalva and standing up suddenly do the opposite.1 Handgrip raises the pressure the heart pumps against and makes aortic regurgitation louder.1,3
For systolic murmurs, maneuvers are most useful for spotting hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. No single maneuver identifies aortic stenosis.10 For these two murmurs, timing does the real work.
What can fool you?
- Both at once. The same diseased valve, often a bicuspid one, can both narrow and leak, so a patient may have a systolic and a diastolic murmur.2,3,4
- Aortic stenosis heard at the apex. In a calcified valve, the high-pitched part of the murmur can carry to the apex, where it can sound like mitral regurgitation. This is called the Gallavardin phenomenon.2
- A stenosis murmur that gets softer. When the ventricle starts to fail and pumps less blood, the murmur can become quieter even though the valve is worse.2
- A diastolic murmur you don't hear. The regurgitation murmur is soft and high-pitched. Without the forward-leaning position, it is easy to overlook.5,7
A murmur is a clue, not a diagnosis: an echocardiogram confirms either lesion and how severe it is.2,3 Listen to aortic stenosis or aortic regurgitation in Auscultate.
References
- Thomas SL, Heaton J, Makaryus AN. Physiology, Cardiovascular Murmurs. In: StatPearls. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; updated 2023 Jul 17. PubMed 30247833 · www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK525958/
- Pujari SH, Agasthi P. Aortic Stenosis. In: StatPearls. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; updated 2023 Apr 16. PubMed 32491560 · www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK557628/
- Patibandla S, Heaton J, Azzam JS. Aortic Insufficiency. In: StatPearls. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; updated 2023 Jul 4. PubMed 32491360 · www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK557428/
- Wenn P, Zeltser R. Aortic Valve Disease. In: StatPearls. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; updated 2023 Jan 9. PubMed 31194362 · www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK542205/
- Malik MB, Goyal A. Cardiac Examination. In: StatPearls. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; updated 2023 Jan 23. PubMed 31971719 · www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK553078/
- Etchells E, Bell C, Robb K. Does this patient have an abnormal systolic murmur? JAMA. 1997;277(7):564-571. PubMed 9032164
- Choudhry NK, Etchells EE. The rational clinical examination. Does this patient have aortic regurgitation? JAMA. 1999;281(23):2231-2238. doi:10.1001/jama.281.23.2231 · PubMed 10376577
- Harvey WP, Corrado MA, Perloff JK. "Right-sided" murmurs of aortic insufficiency (diastolic murmurs better heard to the right of the sternum rather than to the left). Am J Med Sci. 1963;245:533-543. PubMed 13960803
- Munt B, Legget ME, Kraft CD, Miyake-Hull CY, Fujioka M, Otto CM. Physical examination in valvular aortic stenosis: correlation with stenosis severity and prediction of clinical outcome. Am Heart J. 1999;137(2):298-306. doi:10.1053/hj.1999.v137.95496 · PubMed 9924164
- Lembo NJ, Dell'Italia LJ, Crawford MH, O'Rourke RA. Bedside diagnosis of systolic murmurs. N Engl J Med. 1988;318(24):1572-1578. doi:10.1056/NEJM198806163182404 · PubMed 2897627